
Not my hand. Not my Kindle, either.
Once upon a time, our own Secretary of Artistic Propaganda, Natalie Metzger, reviewed the Kobo eReader from Borders Booksellers. When I decided it was time to acquire an eReader, I thought it might be nice to get something different for the purposes of objective comparison. As Overlord Miller owns a Sony eReader and I couldn’t bring myself to own a product named the “Nookie Reader,” I asked Santa for an Amazon Kindle for Christmas.
The latest generation of Amazon’s eReader comes in three flavors: the 6″ wi-fi, which runs about $140, the 6″ wi-fi + 3G, which will set you back $190, and the Kindle DX, which measures 42″ diagonally, comes mounted on a Segway and costs roughly the Gross Domestic Product of Paraguay. I asked for the 6″ wi-fi version and received the 6″ wi-fi + 3G model along with a black leather cover.
The cover is pretty much a must-have. I carry my Kindle in my laptop bag, or tuck it under my arm. Without the cover, the screen would have been smashed to bits on day one. For sixty bucks, you can get a cover with a built-in reading light, but just as I’ve never been a fan of reading pulp and ink books by anything other than natural sunlight or a nearby lamp, I don’t find the idea of a special reading light for the Kindle particularly attractive; I’m also lucky to have a wife who isn’t kept awake if I’ve got my bedside lamp on while I read.
To date, I’ve read The Girl With the Dragon Tattoo by Steig Larsson, Boneshaker by Cherie Priest, issues of The Onion newspaper Asimov and Analog magazines, the MaximumPC blog, and sample chapters of several dozen Kindle novels including Johannes Cabal the Necromancer by Jonathan L. Howard and Hunger Games by Suzanne Collins. Right now, I’m a little over halfway through The Girl Who Played with Fire, the second novel in Steig Larsson’s Millennium trilogy.
Prior to getting the Kindle, I wasn’t 100% sold on the idea of an eReader as an everyday device. I could see using it while traveling—I tend to cart one or more books around in my carryon when I fly, and almost inevitably buy another novel at the airport bookstore—but not as something I’d want to use while sitting around the house. After reading just one novel, my attitude changed completely: I found myself wishing that the books I received as Christmas gifts (or purchased with my Borders gift card) were on my Kindle; I even went so far as to purchase Boneshaker prior to a family vacation in Florida, even though a friend had loaned me his paperback copy to read. On the other hand, it’s nice to know that I can pass my copy of The Best of Joe R. Lansdale on to Overlord Miller when I’ve finished reading it.
The Kindle supports a variety of file formats, including PDF, text, rich text, structured HTML and Microsoft Word. Many of these formats can be converted to the native Kindle format by e-mailing them to {username}@kindle.com or {username}@free.kindle.com. The latter address is handy for 3G Kindle users who don’t want to pay a small fee to have their personal documents delivered over the 3G network; sending the file to the free.kindle.com address ensures that the document will only be delivered when the Kindle is connected to a wi-fi network.
I’ve had good luck converting PDFs to the Kindle format, though the maps standard to most epic fantasy titles don’t convert well. Still, anything beats trying to read a PDF on a mobile device. Since a PDF is essentially a series of images, one per page, there’s no good way to read a PDF formatted for a large page size on a small screen. The result is a lot of zooming and panning, which is a pain. Converting to the Kindle format allows the page layout to scale to the screen, shifting line breaks appropriately.
Unfortunately, not every PDF can be converted. Files with embedded DRM, for example, won’t work, nor will files with some advanced features. When I attempted to convert Roger Ebert’s Awake in the Dark, which was offered as a free download from The University of Chicago Press a few months ago, I was informed that the PDF contained features that were not supported on the Kindle…yet.
Also unsupported is the open EPUB format, which puts the Kindle on a (very) short list of eReaders that are incompatible with most library e-book lending systems. Both the Nook (Barnes & Noble) and the Kobo (Borders) support the EPUB format, and the ability to borrow e-books from my local library would have been nice.
When I was doing my research into eReaders, lack of EPUB support was definitely a strike against the Kindle, but the major competitors had bigger strikes against them. First, Barnes & Noble introduced the Color Nook, which abandons E Ink (more on that in a minute) in favor of a backlit, touchscreen color LCD. The Color Nook wants to be more than just an eReader; it wants to be the Apple iPad’s cheap cousin. Borders hasn’t tried to make the Kobo anything more than an eReader (yet), but my experience with Borders as an online store has been less than stellar; Barnes & Noble’s website (in the most recent iteration I’ve seen) is even worse. Amazon, on the other hand, has been an online retailer from day one, and they do electronic sales very well. It was this, more than almost anything else, that convinced me the Kindle was my eReader.
But it was E Ink that sold me. After taking a co-worker’s Kindle for a test drive one day, it was clear that E Ink is ideal for reading on a mobile device: crisp, clean text, almost no glare, and best of all, no backlight. I’ve had the Kindle app installed on my laptop and desktop computers for the better part of a year, yet I’ve never read a book on either device. Why? Because I hate reading on a computer screen. Anything more than a few paragraphs of a blog at a time and it’s a chore. Once my Kindle was in my hands, I found that I could read on it for hours at a time without strain. The form factor helps—it’s just a little larger than a standard paperback—but the E Ink brings the magic and keeps me reading.
The Kindle is not for everyone. If you think spending $140 on an eReader will somehow magically grant you access to all the free or dirt-cheap books you could possibly want for the rest of your life, you’re absolutely correct—as long as you’re content reading works that have fallen into the public domain. New books on the Kindle will cost almost as much or more than their paperback counterparts (though rarely anywhere near the hardcover editions); if you’re of the opinion that the medium, not the content, should drive the price, and believe (incorrectly) that there is little or no publisher cost involved in offering an e-book edition, the Kindle probably isn’t for you; nor is most any eReader.
If you’re looking for an eReader that doubles as a web browser or gaming platform, the Kindle is probably not for you. There is an “experimental” web browser included on the Kindle, but it’s not particularly enjoyable to use. A quick lookup on Wikipedia once in a blue moon, perhaps; everyday web browsing, no way. And there are games on the Kindle as well—I have a few word games (Scrabble, Every Word, Shuffled Row) and a sort of Choose Your Own Adventure game, Choice of Broadsides—but the response time while playing games is slow (even though pages turn very quickly when reading a book) and playing games kills the battery as fast or faster than turning on the wireless connection. Still, I did work through thirty New York Times crossword puzzles while I was going through my serious “Kindle-as-gadget” phase about a week after Christmas. I’m happy to report that I’ve moved beyond that phase, and my Kindle is now just an eReader. A very, very good one.